Alimony And Maintenance Rights In Indian Divorce

One of the major challenges following divorce is the financial impact, particularly on the economically weaker spouse. To remedy this situation, Indian law provides for alimony and maintenance to ensure that the dependent spouse, children, and sometimes parents can lead a life free from economic hardship after divorce. Moreover, property is often considered a means to secure a dignified life post-divorce.

Definition of Alimony  

Alimony is the monetary support provided to a spouse following divorce to ensure their financial security and well-being, either as a lump sum or as regular payments.

Definition of Maintenance

Maintenance is a broader concept that includes financial support provided during and after marriage. It covers court-ordered spousal maintenance, child support, and, in some cases, support payable to parents by their children. 

Alimony vs Maintenance  

Definition:

• Alimony: Payments made by one spouse to another as a means of support after divorce. 
• Maintenance: Support given during or after marriage, covering spouses, children, and occasionally parents.

Maintenance Payment Duration:

• Alimony: Paid only after divorce.  
• Maintenance: Can be awarded during or after marriage (including during divorce proceedings).  

Scope:

• Alimony: Generally, it applies to spousal support only.  
• Maintenance: Covers spouse, children, and even dependent parents (under Section 125 CrPC/Section 144 of BNSS).  

Nature of Payment:

• Alimony: Can be paid as a lump sum or periodic payments.  
• Maintenance: Usually periodic payments (monthly or as per court order).  

Legal Basis:

• Alimony: Granted under personal laws like the Hindu Marriage Act, Special Marriage Act, etc.  
• Maintenance: Covered under personal laws and secular law (Section 125 CrPC/Section 144 of BNSS), applicable to all religions.  

Purpose:

• Alimony: To secure the financial needs of a spouse after the divorce. 
• Section 125 CrPC Maintenance: Maintenance serves to keep body and soul together, maintaining certain basic needs, including shelter, clothing, etc., both during and after separation/divorce.

Legal Framework for Alimony and Maintenance

Alimony and maintenance prove different things under various laws, based on parties’ religion or the type of marriage.

Hindu Marriage Act (HMA): 

• Section 24: Any person whose spouse is not able to maintain himself or herself can apply to the Court during the pendency of all divorce proceedings.
• Section 25: The husband is obliged to serve any woman after the divorce as a whole or to a certain extent, according to the provisions advised by the Court taking into consideration the financial needs of the husband/wife.

Special Marriage Act, 1954:

Section 37: Permanent alimony and maintenance to spouses married under the Special Marriage Act.

Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937:

• Under sharia law, a divorced Muslim woman can receive maintenance for three months following the divorce only.
• More recently, following the court’s decision in Shah Bano Case (1985) and the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act (1986), a divorced woman may seek maintenance from her ex-husband or the Wakf board.

Indian Divorce Act, 1869 (for Christians):

Sections 36 & 37 respectively provide for interim and permanent maintenance for Christian women.

Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936:

Section 39 allows alimony for a wife post-divorce.

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Section 125 CrPC)/ Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (Section 144 of BNSS):

Section 125/Section 144 of BNSS provides for maintenance of the wives, kids, and parents for all religions.

Types of Alimony and Maintenance

• Interim Maintenance: Awarded during trial in divorce proceedings to meet immediate expenses.
• Permanent Alimony: Long-term financial support following divorce.
• Lump Sum vs. Periodic Payments: 

• Lump Sum: A one-time settlement.
• Periodic Payments: Regular monthly or yearly support.

Alimony Eligibility India 

Factors Considered by the Court:

• Financial Status of Both Parties
• Duration of Marriage (longer marriages may warrant higher alimony)
• Conduct of Spouses (adultery or cruelty may impact maintenance claims)
• Earning Capacity and Employment Status (of both spouses)

Rights of Wife vs. Rights of Husband:

While traditionally alimony has been awarded mainly to wives, recent judgments have allowed for the maintenance rights for husbands under Sections 125 of CrPC/ Section 144 of BNSS or 24 if dependent on the wife. 

Maintenance for Children and Parents:

• Children are entitled to financial support from both parents.
• Under Section 125 CrPC/Section 144 of BNSS, aged parents can also claim maintenance from their children.

Determining Factors for Granting Alimony

• Financial Status of Both Parties: Courts assess income, assets, and liabilities.
• Duration of Marriage: Longer marriages often result in higher and longer maintenance.
• Conduct of Spouses: Misconduct (like adultery or cruelty) may impact alimony decisions.
• Earning Capacity: If both spouses are equally financially stable, alimony may be reduced or denied.

Landmark Divorce Cases India 

• Shah Bano Case (1985): A landmark decision by the Supreme Court that held that a Muslim woman can seek maintenance after the Iddah period under Section 125 of the CrPC. 
• Kusum Sharma v. Mahinder Kumar Sharma (2020): It has laid down the guidelines for determination of the amount of alimony.
• Rajnesh v. Neha (2020): Made financial affidavits mandatory for maintenance claims.

Procedure for Claiming Alimony and Maintenance

• Filing a Petition: The spouse seeking maintenance must file a claim in court.
• Court Proceedings and Legal Process: 

• Financial affidavits are submitted.
• Courts evaluate claims and pass appropriate orders.
• Execution and Enforcement of Orders: Non-payment can lead to legal actions, including salary attachment and even imprisonment.

Tax Implications of Alimony and Maintenance

Income Tax Treatment: 

• Lump Sum Alimony: Not taxable.
• Periodic Alimony: Taxable as income for the recipient.
• For the Payer: No tax deduction is allowed

Modification and Termination of Alimony Orders

• Change in Financial Positional Evaluation: Either party may seek modification in the event of a change of their finances.
• Marriage or Cohabitation by the Recipient: Alimony is directed to terminate upon the remarriage of the recipient (or cohabitation).
• Death of Either Party: The payment of alimony ceases with the death of the payor or the recipient.

Challenges and Issues in Alimony Cases

• Delay in Legal Proceedings: Family courts often take years to resolve maintenance cases.
• Non-Compliance and Enforcement Issues: Many ex-spouses fail to pay maintenance, causing financial hardship for the dependent spouse.
• Gender Bias and Fairness Concerns: Women are usually favoured in alimony cases, but courts now recognize maintenance rights for husbands.

Conclusion 

Alimony and maintenance laws play a crucial role in ensuring financial security after divorce. While the system has evolved, challenges remain in enforcement and achieving gender neutrality. Future reforms should aim for fair, uniform, and efficient maintenance laws.

One can talk to a lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.

FAQs

1. Who is the rightful claimant for alimony or maintenance under Indian law?

Alimony is awarded to a spouse who proves to be the financially dependent party after the divorce. Maintenance can be awarded to the spouse during marriage, children, and dependent parents. The courts determine the financial position of the parties, the duration of the marriage, and the capacity of the concerned parties to earn therefrom.

2. Can the husband ask his wife for maintenance in India?

As per the existing judicial precedent, a husband can indeed file for maintenance from his wife, under the Hindu Marriage Act, Special Marriage Act, and Section 125 CrPC/Section 144 of BNSS, in case he cannot maintain himself and requires financial support from her.

3. Is alimony a one-time payment or a regular payment?

It could either be a once-off payment (lump sum) or a recurring payment (monthly/annual) that depends on the court grant and the financial condition of both parties.